I like them too. My favorite songs from them would have to be a tie between "Dear Agony" "The Diary of Jane" "You" "So Cold" and "Crawl". My favorite albums from them are 'Shallow Bay: The Best of Breaking Benjamin' and 'Dear Agony'.
I LOVE Breaking Benjamin! They're one of my favorite bands! My favorite songs by them are probably "The Diary of Jane," "Into the Nothing," and "Without You." I have all four of their albums, but I'm more familiar with Phobia and Dear Agony. (: I hope they can clear up all that's going on in the band and continue making music soon...